Job seekers/Working with a recruiter
Guide 03
How working with a recruiter really works.
There is one piece of how recruiting works that rarely gets explained well, and not knowing it can quietly cost good people opportunities. So here is the whole mechanism, written plainly, including the parts that usually go unsaid.
Who pays, and why it matters
The employer pays. Always. You never pay anything.
When an employer hires me to fill a role, they pay a fee, typically a percentage of the new hire's first year base salary. That fee is paid by the company, after you start. Not by you, not out of your paycheck, not deducted from your salary.
The misunderstanding that costs people jobs
A lot of candidates believe that because the employer pays a fee, their own offer gets reduced to cover it, so going through a recruiter means taking less money. That is not how it works. The fee is a separate business expense, on top of your compensation, and your salary is negotiated on its own terms.
If anything, it works the other way around. Nothing on my end of this improves by talking you into a smaller number, so when I say I think you can ask for more, you can take that at face value. Helping you get paid fairly for what you can actually do is part of the job, not a favor.
One other thing worth saying out loud: because the employer is paying a fee, they are hoping for people they could not easily have found on their own. So a recruiter may pass on you for a role you could genuinely do well. I know that stings. It is honestly not a verdict on you or your work.
Who a recruiter actually works for
Here is the part that often goes unsaid, and I would rather you hear it from me directly. The employer is the client who pays me, and I am accountable to them. That is simply how the work is structured, and you deserve to know it going in instead of piecing it together halfway through.
What it does not mean is that you are on your own in this. What a recruiter can genuinely promise you is different from representation, and day to day it is often more useful:
- Nothing happens to your information without your permission. Your resume does not move until you say yes to a named employer.
- You get told the truth about where you stand, including when the answer is no, and including the actual reason.
- You are not strung along. If the role is filled, or you are out, you hear it from me rather than from silence.
- Someone is advocating for you in the negotiation. A placement only really works if you are happy in it, so pushing for terms you can live with is in everyone's interest.
That is a real relationship, and I take my end of it seriously. Knowing exactly what it is just means nothing catches you off guard along the way.
The four kinds, and how to tell them apart
People use "recruiter," "headhunter," "staffing agency," and "HR" interchangeably. They are genuinely different jobs, and what you should expect from each one is different.
| Type | How they get paid | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Contingency search Most independent and boutique recruiters, including Waymark |
A percentage of first year base salary, paid only if the employer hires someone the recruiter presented. No hire, no fee. | They are motivated and they move fast. They are also selective, since they are only paid when a placement lands. The upside of that is you tend to get a straight answer about your odds instead of being kept warm for months. |
| Retained search Executive level |
Paid in installments regardless of outcome, usually for senior roles at larger organizations. | Slower, more thorough, deeper vetting. Almost always exclusive on the role, so there is one legitimate path in. |
| Staffing agency Temp, temp to hire, contract |
Marks up an hourly rate. You are the agency's employee, on their payroll, with their benefits, placed at a client site. | Fast entry, real income, real experience, a genuinely good option in some situations. Just know that you are not the client company's employee, and temp to hire conversion is a hope rather than a guarantee. It is completely fair to ask what their conversion rate actually is. |
| Internal / corporate recruiter In house talent acquisition |
A salaried employee of the company you are applying to. | They only have that company's jobs. They are usually juggling many openings at once. Slower to respond, but they are inside the building and can tell you exactly what the culture is. |
For transparency: Waymark is contingency, direct hire, Western New York only. If you are placed through me you are the employer's employee from day one, on their payroll, with their benefits. You are never employed by Waymark. And I do not do temp or contract work, so if that is what you need, an actual staffing agency will serve you better and I will tell you so.
The submission rule, and why you must never break it
This is the single most practical thing in this guide, and it is worth a slow read.
Never let two parties submit you to the same employer
If two recruiters present you to the same company, or if a recruiter presents you somewhere you already applied directly, it creates an ownership dispute over who gets the fee. Employers handle that dispute the easy way: they drop the candidate. Not the recruiters. You.
I have watched genuinely strong people get eliminated from a process they would have won, over a fee argument they had no idea was happening.
How to protect yourself, and it is easy:
- Keep a list of every place you have applied, directly or through anyone else, with dates. A note on your phone is enough. Six weeks in, almost nobody can hold the whole list in their head, and that is usually right when it matters.
- Require the company name before you consent. Any legitimate recruiter will tell you who the employer is before sending anything. If someone wants blanket permission to shop your resume around without naming who they are sending it to, it is completely reasonable to say no. That one question protects you more than anything else on this page.
- Say so immediately if you have already applied there. "I applied to them directly in July." Not a problem, and it saves everyone. Hiding it is what causes damage.
- Give permission per employer, not in general. One yes per company, every time.
Most presentation rights last a set window, commonly somewhere in the range of six to twelve months, depending on the agreement between the recruiter and the employer. If you were presented to a company last spring and it did not work out, ask before anyone sends you back in.
What actually happens, step by step
- Your resume arrives. Either you applied to a posted role, sent a general application, or I found you.
- Screening call, roughly twenty to thirty minutes. What you do now, what you want next, your number, your commute limits, your timeline, whether you are working and need discretion. I tell you what is actually open, including the pay range and the parts of the job people do not love.
- You consent, by name. I tell you the employer. You say yes or no. Nothing leaves my hands before that.
- Submission. Your resume goes over with a written summary of why you fit, which is a real part of the value. A hiring manager reading a two paragraph explanation of your background reads your resume differently than one pulling it cold out of a pile of ninety.
- Feedback, and this is where recruiters earn or lose your trust. You should hear something within a few business days, including a no. If a client goes quiet, you should hear that they went quiet.
- Interview, and prep beforehand. This is the biggest structural advantage of going through a recruiter. I know who is interviewing you, what they asked the last three candidates, what they passed on people for, and what they care about. Take the prep call. The interview guide covers the rest.
- Debrief both directions. I ask how it went before I hear from them, because your read matters and because when they raise a concern I want to have already heard your side of it.
- Offer and negotiation. I usually know the employer's actual flexibility, and I can test a number without you having to risk the relationship doing it yourself.
- Resignation, start date, and the first few weeks. A good recruiter helps you resign cleanly, prepares you for the counteroffer, and checks in after you start. If you are unhappy at ninety days, I want to hear it, and I would much rather help you sort it out than find out about it later.
What to tell a recruiter, even when it is uncomfortable
Everything in this list is something I would much rather know up front than discover late, because late is when it costs you the offer.
- Your actual number. Not a bluff. If you need seventy, say seventy. I will give you a straight answer about whether that exists in this market for this kind of work, and if it does not, at least you know that now rather than after months of looking.
- Everywhere you have applied. See the submission rule.
- Your real commute limit. A forty five minute drive each way feels very manageable in September and very different in February when the Thruway closes. It helps to think about it in January terms.
- Whether you are working and need confidentiality. Say it plainly. It changes how and when I contact you and what I do with references.
- Anything that will surface in a background check. A conviction, a credit issue for a finance role, a degree you did not finish. Told up front, these are usually manageable. Discovered at the background check stage, they tend to end the process, because at that point it reads as concealment even when it was nothing of the kind.
- Other processes you are in, and your timeline. If you have a final round elsewhere next week, that is leverage, and it lets me push a client to move.
- Your dealbreakers. No weekends. Must be home by five for daycare. Cannot travel. Will not do outbound calls. Say them early. Every one of these is fine. None of them is fine at offer stage for the first time.
- Why you are leaving, honestly. Part of my job is helping you frame it well for an employer, and I cannot do that nearly as well if I am only hearing the polished version.
What you can keep to yourself
You are not obligated to disclose everything, and a decent recruiter will not push on these.
- Your current or past salary. In New York, employers are prohibited from asking about your salary history or relying on it in setting your pay. That protection has been in effect statewide since January 6, 2020. You can decline to answer and pivot to what you are targeting. The pay guide covers exactly how.
- Age, date of birth, graduation year. Not relevant, not required, and legitimately risky for an employer to be collecting.
- Marital status, children, pregnancy, family plans. None of it is anyone's business, and asking it is a problem for the asker.
- Religion, national origin, citizenship details beyond the yes or no of whether you are legally authorized to work in the United States.
- Disability or medical history. Only the question of whether you can perform the job's actual functions, with or without accommodation, is on the table.
- Your reference list, until you are genuinely close. Do not let your references be called four times for four roles you are only loosely being considered for. You will burn them, and you need them.
If a recruiter keeps pressing on any of these after you have politely declined, that tells you something useful about how the rest of the relationship would probably go.
What a recruiter can and cannot do for you
Can
- Get your resume read by an actual decision maker instead of a portal
- Tell you the pay range before you invest time in the process
- Tell you what this hiring manager has passed on other candidates for
- Explain a gap or a short stint on your behalf, before it is held against you
- Show you roles that were never posted anywhere
- Test a salary number without you risking the relationship
- Tell you the unflattering parts of the job before you accept it
- Give you a straight answer on why you were passed over
Cannot
- Make an employer hire you. The decision is never mine.
- Get you hired into a job you would not be set up to succeed in
- Create a role that does not exist for a candidate they like
- Rewrite the employer's budget
- Guarantee a timeline. Clients go quiet, priorities change, headcount freezes.
- Be your full time career coach, though I am always glad to talk through where you are trying to go
- Have a role open in your field at the exact moment you need one
That last one on the left is worth dwelling on. In a market the size of Buffalo, a meaningful share of good jobs at small employers never get posted at all. An owner with a hundred people and no HR department has no realistic way to read several hundred resumes, so they call someone. Being on a recruiter's list is how you see those, and it is the single strongest argument for sending a resume in even when nothing posted fits you today.
Warning signs: walk away
- They ask you for money. Any fee, for any reason, in order to be considered for a job. Placement fee, resume fee, "database access," background check fee, training you must buy. Walk. This is the brightest line there is.
- They will not name the employer before submitting you. Confidential searches are completely normal, and the employer's name may not be on the public posting. But before your resume moves anywhere, you should be told exactly who it is going to, every single time.
- They sent your resume without asking. The submission rule exists for your protection. Someone who breaks it is risking your candidacy to protect their fee.
- The job in the conversation is not the job in the posting. Bait and switch. You called about an accounting role and now it is a commission only sales role.
- Pressure to accept fast, with a manufactured deadline. A real offer survives you reading it overnight.
- They will not tell you the pay range. In New York, a posting for a job that will be performed in state has to include a good faith range. If there is no range and no straight answer when you ask, something is off.
- They ask for your Social Security number, date of birth, or bank details early. Those come at the background check and onboarding stage, through the employer's system, after an offer. Not in an email from a recruiter you have spoken to once.
- The whole thing lives in text messages and a personal email address, there is no real web presence, and the "interview" is a chat app. That is a recruitment scam, they are common, and the goal is your identity or a fake check.
- They talk about other candidates by name. If they gossip about other people's searches to you, yours is being discussed elsewhere.
How to get the most out of a recruiter
- Pick ones who actually work your lane. Two or three recruiters who specialize in your function and your geography are worth more than fifteen generalists. A recruiter outside your field may genuinely want to help you and simply have nothing to offer.
- Answer the phone, and call back the same day. Speed genuinely matters. Roles get filled in two weeks around here. The candidate who returns the call Tuesday morning gets the interview slot.
- Be candid, especially about the awkward parts. The whole relationship runs on the recruiter being able to represent you accurately. A surprise late in the process hurts you far more than the underlying fact ever would.
- Take the prep call. Every time. It is free inside information about the person deciding your candidacy, and it is the easiest advantage on this whole list to pick up.
- Tell them when you are out. If you accept something else or decide to stay put, say so. It costs you one text and it means you are remembered well the next time, which in a market this small matters more than people think.
- Ask for the real feedback and then actually use it. "What would have made me stronger for that role?" The answer is often specific and fixable, and it is the most valuable thing a recruiter gives you for free.
- Stay in touch every couple of months when you are not looking. One short email. The people I place fastest are the ones I already know.
Working with more than one
You should, and it is completely normal. Nobody has every job. Two things to manage:
Track submissions obsessively, so two recruiters never send you to the same place. And there is no need to hide that you are working with others. It is completely fine that you are talking to three recruiters. What I do worry about is accidentally double submitting you and getting you disqualified over something neither of us saw coming.
Be careful with the ones who ask you to sign an exclusive. For a job seeker, exclusivity is almost never in your interest. You are not obligated to give anyone the exclusive right to represent you, and for most office and professional roles there is no good reason to.
The two sentence version
The employer pays, you never do, and your resume should never move to a company you have not been told the name of. Everything else in this guide is detail on top of those two facts.
Waymark is one person, working Western New York only, for employers with roughly five to a hundred and twenty five people and no HR department. When you apply here, I am the one who reads it and I am the one who calls you.
- Call(716) 225-6347
- EmailEmail Jamie
- Based inLancaster, NY
Get on the list
Most of what gets filled around here never gets posted. Send a resume once and you are in front of a person for everything that comes next.
Send your resumeThis guide is general information for job seekers, not legal advice. New York employment law changes, and how a rule applies depends on your specific situation. If you believe an employer has broken the law in how it treated you, talk to the New York State Department of Labor or an employment attorney.
Keep going
How to prepare for an interview
The ninety second rule, a story bank that covers most behavioral questions, and how to handle the salary question in New York.
Read the guide → Guide 04What jobs pay in Western New York
How to find out what a role pays before you apply, and how to set a number you can hold in a conversation.
Read the guide →